Ah, but a man's reach should exceed his grasp,
Or what's a heaven for? - Robert Browning, “Andrea del Sarto” Or a woman’s reach. What Barbie left me mulling has less to do with feminism or patriarchy than whether expectations of perfection boost or squash self-esteem. As a schoolgirl I brought home the happy news that I could be anything I wanted. My spoilsport father said it wasn’t true. Alas, he was right. Spectacular achievements take not only grit but some innate skill and some degree of luck. Not everyone who aspires to be an astronaut, a U.S. president, or an Olympic athlete will become one, no matter how hard she strives. Will she feel like a failure, as I did after an unsuccessful job search, or will role-playing with those Barbies inspire a healthy interest in science, politics, or sports? Some say perfection is excellence taken even further. I’d suggest the opposite. Perfectionism promotes limits. Don’t try new things you may do poorly. Stay within the safety of the known. Pursuit of excellence, on the other hand, opens a world of possibilities. Some will work out; others won’t. You win some; you lose some. Adventure. Explore. Ask questions. Admit your mistakes. You may not reach Mars or the Olympics, but you may discover places you never dreamed of—and have fun along the way. Photo: My grandmother’s, my mother’s, and my best dolls represented neither babies nor fashion models but girls a little older than ourselves.
2 Comments
Peter McLaughlin
2/12/2024 07:16:17 am
This is GREAT - it also applies to men!
Reply
2/12/2024 02:28:28 pm
Peter, yes! And good to hear it from a man. I was thinking of that too, a little surprised that my lingering thought from such a girly/feminist movie wasn't gender-specific. I made it to seventh grade before I learned that missing one question on a test wasn't the same as failing it. I've been fortunate to have had family members (men, as most of my family members are) who modeled that spirit of adventure and experiment, and who achieved excellence without the unhealthy limits of perfectionism.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorI'm a historian who writes novels and literary nonfiction. My home base is Madison, Wisconsin. Archives
October 2024
|