We’re in the throes of another election season. Candidates and voters deny election results from 2020 or from recent primary defeats. Meanwhile, Covid-19 responses add to a long history of science denial, in the tradition of the Flat Earth Society or nineteenth-century doctors’ refusal to wash their hands.
Perhaps some people can’t stand the tension of beliefs that conflict with their wishes. Perhaps some haven’t heard the factual evidence. Perhaps some spread lies deliberately for profit, ratings, or votes. But top factors in the appeal of denialism surely include belonging and distrust.
To be shut out from community because of differences of belief brings pain. We’re influenced by those around us not only because we think they know best but because we want and need their acceptance. If we deny evidence to stay in the group, what’s most likely to change our minds is exposure to supportive new friends with a different perspective.
To feel scorned or ignored by perceived elites breeds distrust of authority. Unlike skepticism, which demands evidence, denialism rejects legal and scientific authority regardless of evidence. If we deny expertise in order to claim our equal right to an opinion, the most effective antidote might be mutually respectful conversations free from superior sneers.
8/8/2022 07:29:38 am
Election deniers are members of their own reference groups so their identity is tied into their beliefs. All beliefs come from some sacred part of ourselves - whether or not they are useful or detrimental to society. We need to honor all individuals, regardless of their beliefs while we work to support the success of our own beliefs.
8/8/2022 08:57:33 am
So important to remember. And such a challenge to honor the individuals regardless of beliefs, without necessarily honoring the false and detrimental beliefs. The tie of identity to beliefs makes it unlikely we'll change anyone's mind, especially if we try to do so by disrespecting the individual.
Leave a Reply.
I'm a historian who writes novels and literary nonfiction. My home base is Madison, Wisconsin.